Witch Hat Cookies

Category / Dessert
Witch Hat Cookies

These witch hats will give you warlocks and sorcerers a chance to use your creative magic. Using only 3 ingredients, this delicious, vegan recipe is a fun way to celebrate Halloween with your friends and family.


Robin Means of Vegan Dollhouse
Developed by

Robin Means of Vegan Dollhouse

Robin has spent the last 6 years developing recipes for VeganDollhouse.com. When she’s not making cute food and blogging, Robin spends her time crafting, sewing, live streaming, podcasting, and organizing and attending tea parties. As a longtime vegan (20 years and counting), she loves all animals, especially her rescue doggo, Macchiato.
Learn More

Serves 12 hats Easy


  1. Open the chocolate sandwich cookies and remove the cream filling. We’re only using the halves with no cream inside.  
  2. Melt two Amy’s Dreamy candy bars in the microwave for 15 seconds. (I used two candy bars to make six hats). Stir the melted candy bars until they start to turn into a moldable consistency.  
  3. Roll about a sixth of the melted chocolate into a ball. If you’re having trouble removing all the cream from the cookies, use the melted mixture to pick up the remaining cream (sort of like Silly Putt!y). 
  4. Roll the candy bar putty into a ball and shape into a cone. Press the cone onto a cookie half. Using your fingers, mold the melted chocolate into a hat shape. (I prefer the slouchy hat tip, but you can make them pointy if you'd like.)  
  5. Mold one hat and place in the freezer for 5-10 minutes while you make the next hat. You'll want to place each hat in the freezer immediately after molding so they can keep their shape. After they've all chilled, you can decorate them with vegan star sprinkles! 

Pro tip

To make this recipe gluten free, use gluten free sandwich cookies. They will stay good for a week in the fridge.